TIWN Aug 8, 2024
New Delhi, Aug 8 : Amid the Middle East's gradual slide into a wider conflict, three incidents are telling - a ceasefire proposal announced by the leader of a superpower is gradually undermined and soon vanishes from discourse, a ceasefire negotiator is assassinated in a provocative gambit, and a hardliner is elevated to replace him. Does diplomacy have a future in resolving conflict in the region?
Exactly ten months into the outbreak of conflict in Gaza following the audacious Hamas attack on Israel on October 7, the violence continues unabated and hopes of a negotiated solution are fast receding amid a raft of escalatory measures by all sides.
Let's take the three incidents alluded to above in order.
On May 31, US President Joe Biden, amid criticism of the mounting civilian death toll in the Israeli retaliation, announced that Israel has agreed to a proposal that would lead to a “lasting” ceasefire in the Gaza Strip.
He termed it "a comprehensive new proposal”, which would be "a roadmap to an enduring ceasefire", and unfold in three phases - the six-week first stage, which would comprise "a full and complete ceasefire", the withdrawal of Israeli forces from all populated areas of Gaza, a number of Israeli captives – especially the women and the elderly – released in exchange for hundreds of Palestinian prisoners, and flow of humanitarian aid in the beleaguered enclave.
The second phase was to comprise the release of “all remaining living" Israeli hostages, the withdrawal of Israeli forces, and a permanent "cessation of hostilities".
The final phase was a reconstruction plan for Gaza and the return of remains of any captives killed, Biden said, stressing that if the negotiations from phase one to phase two took more time, the ceasefire would anyway continue.
While Hamas had welcomed the US President's call, Israel's response to what the US President had termed a proposal endorsed by it was scarcely encouraging. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu pointedly refrained from admitting his acceptance of the proposal and said the war would continue till "total victory".
Israeli military action in Gaza has only intensified since then and despite a raft of negotiations between the two sides, facilitated by Egypt and Qatar, Biden's ceasefire plan seems consigned to limbo, and the US President engaged in a rare outburst at the Israeli leader this week, as per media reports.
This is indicative of diminishing US leverage over Israel and the Netanyahu government, which has casually ignored all advice - not to attack Rafeh, allow more aid, steps to minimise civilian deaths, etc.
Then came the assassination of Hamas political bureau chief Ismail Haniyeh in Tehran, hours after attending the inauguration of Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian on July 30 - in another key signal against a negotiated settlement.
- PM Modi holds bilateral talks with Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi
- Current situation in Gaza India's foremost concern: EAM Jaishankar
- Indian Navy's P-8I aircraft arrives in Darwin for multinational maritime exercise
- Israel strikes research facility, arms depot in Syria: Monitor
- My role is to inject love, respect, humility: Rahul Gandhi at diaspora meet in US